one critic remarked, Starship Troopers is a "smart movie that
pretends to be dumb." It takes the controversial Robert A. Heinlein
novel - you know the one in which Heinlein re-staged World War II in outer space
with the fascists as the heroes this time around - and doesn't take it seriously
for a moment. After all, how can one honestly take Heinlein's future society in
which one has to do military service before attaining the vote seriously? Okay,
so Heinlein did maybe - and if you do as well, I would suggest that you seek immediate
help. (Remember that it is really no accident that Charles Manson was a big fan
of Heinlein, especially his Stranger In A Strange Land.)
If you are a fan of the novel, then you'd probably be horrified by what director
Paul Verhoeven (RoboCop (1987), Total Recall (1990)) did
with Starship Troopers. Not merely the liberties he took with the
basic storyline (yeah, the novel's famous jump suits doesn't feature at all in
the movie), but also the sly commentary he keeps on making about the material
at hand. If you haven't read the book, but take the movie seriously as well, then,
oh well, I suppose that you've missed the point then.
how can you take a bunch of Aryan "Melrose Place" beautiful teenager
types dressed up as stormtroopers and Gestapo officers and sent off to outer space
to hunt big bugs serious? The film is also in on the joke and while the first
half is weak and slow moving, it is enlivened by small Internet-like infomercials
- much like the occasional newscasts in RoboCop (1987). The second half in
which all kinds of battles with the bugs take place is better since it is here
where Verhoeven's strengths lie: staging wild, over-the-top energetic ultraviolence.
Soldiers' heads and limbs get lopped off, they are burned alive, their brains
sucked out and so forth. But there is a certain Doom computer game-like quality
to these scenes.
Sure, some scenes in the movie are as dumb as they get. (Surely there has
to be better way to go about fighting these insects than using underpowered machine
guns? Why still use such machine guns when you've already achieved interstellar
flight?) But that's just part of the fun. Ultimately Starship Troopers
deserved a bigger audience than it got upon its release in the States. But watch
this film: it is destined to be a sci-fi cult favorite...
Review by James O'Ehley from The
Sci-Fi Movie Page.